Meet the Real-Life Loves of the “We Were Liars” Cast (Including the Couple Who Hard-Launched Their Romance in an Epic Way)

The “We Were Liars” cast has captured the hearts of viewers with their exceptional performances and intriguing storylines. The mystery series, which premiered on June 18, has left audiences enthralled with its complex twists and romantic connections between characters. Lead actors Emily Alyn Lind and Shubham Maheshwari, who portray Cady and Gat in the show, recently shed light on the intricacies of their characters’ relationship in a candid June 2025 interview. Describing their love as unconventional and forbidden, the duo compared it to iconic tales like Romeo and Juliet, adding layers of complexity to their on-screen chemistry.

In real life, the romantic lives of the cast members are not as convoluted as their on-screen personas. While Lind and Maheshwari choose to keep their personal relationships private, other cast members like Caitlin Fitzgerald, who plays Cady’s mom Penny, and Candice King, who portrays Cady’s aunt Bess, are more open about their romantic partners. Fitzgerald is married to Irish actor Aidan Turner, whom she met on the set of a film in 2018, with whom she shares a son. Turner has expressed his love for married life and the joy of building a family with Fitzgerald in various interviews, showcasing a glimpse into their blissful relationship.

Candice King, known for her role as Bess Sinclair in “We Were Liars,” recently got engaged to her former co-star Steven Krueger. The couple’s love story blossomed over the years, starting from their time working together on “The Vampire Diaries” spinoff. King shared the exciting news on social media, expressing her happiness at finding love again. Their engagement signifies a new chapter in King’s life, following her previous marriage to singer Joe King. The couple’s decision to take their relationship slow, considering King’s children from her previous marriage, reflects a thoughtful approach to blending their families and building a future together.

David Morse, who portrays the patriarch of the Sinclair family, Harris Sinclair, has been happily married to Susan Wheeler Duff since 1982. The couple’s enduring love story is a testament to their commitment and bond over the years. Morse has spoken openly about the profound impact Duff has had on his life and their family, highlighting her unwavering support and dedication. Their shared adventures, including a cross-country road trip during the pandemic, showcase the depth of their relationship and the joy they find in each other’s company.

As the real-life loves of the “We Were Liars” cast, these actors’ relationships offer a glimpse into the personal lives of the stars behind the captivating characters on screen. From hidden romances to public declarations of love, each cast member brings a unique love story to the table, enriching their portrayals on the show with their own experiences and emotions. As fans continue to follow their favourite actors on and off the screen, these real-life love stories add a touch of magic to the world of showbiz, reminding us that true love can indeed transcend fiction.