Celebrity Doppelgängers Matthew Gray Gubler and Andrew Durand Come Face-to-Face at Broadway’s “Dead Outlaw ”(Exclusive)

The highly-anticipated meeting of celebrity doppelgängers Matthew Gray Gubler and Andrew Durand recently captivated audiences at Broadway’s Dead Outlaw. The two stars finally came face-to-face, sparking excitement among fans who have long noticed their striking resemblance. A source revealed to PEOPLE that Gubler, best known for his role on “Criminal Minds”, was taken by surprise when he discovered that Durand was leading the show. The meeting, filled with jokes and laughter, left both actors amazed at their uncanny likeness.

This chance encounter between Gubler and Durand took place backstage at the Longacre Theatre in New York City, where Dead Outlaw is currently staged. The musical has garnered widespread acclaim, receiving seven nominations for the 2025 Tony Awards, including Best Musical. Durand’s stellar performance in the lead role has earned him a nomination for Best Actor, further adding to the production’s success.

Both Gubler and Durand have garnered attention online for their resemblance, with many fans pointing out their similarities. Their backstage meeting allowed them to exchange jokes about mistaken identities and the constant comparisons they receive. The source shared that Gubler was particularly taken aback, repeatedly commenting, “It’s like looking in a mirror!” This unexpected meeting was a delightful moment for both actors and a treat for their fans.

Despite not expecting to meet, Gubler and Durand’s encounter was filled with laughter and camaraderie. Gubler, unaware of Durand’s role in the show, was thrilled to support his friend JR Atkins, who was part of the musical’s band. It wasn’t until the performance began that Gubler realised Durand’s involvement, leading to a humourous realization of their shared connection. The moment was a reminder of their unique bond and the entertainment industry’s small world.

Dead Outlaw, which tells the real-life story of American outlaw Elmer McCurdy, has captivated audiences with its dark humour and inventive storytelling. The musical’s unconventional narrative and stellar performances have earned it critical acclaim, including several prestigious theatre awards. The production’s success underscores the talent of the cast and crew, with Durand’s portrayal of McCurdy receiving widespread praise.

The bizarre tale of Elmer McCurdy’s posthumous journey has resonated with audiences since Dead Outlaw’s Off-Broadway debut. The show’s transition to Broadway has further solidified its place in the theatre world, drawing in audiences with its unique storyline and captivating performances. Tickets for the production are in high demand, reflecting the growing popularity of this unconventional and engaging musical.

For Durand, the success of Dead Outlaw marks a significant milestone in his career, with a Tony Award nomination recognising his exceptional performance. The actor expressed his excitement and gratitude for the opportunity to be part of such a special production. Meanwhile, Gubler is gearing up for his return to television with the upcoming series “Einstein”, continuing to showcase his versatility and talent in the entertainment industry.

The meeting of Gubler and Durand at Broadway’s Dead Outlaw not only delighted fans but also highlighted the shared experiences and connections within the entertainment world. As the two actors continue to pursue their respective careers, their uncanny resemblance and mutual admiration serve as a reminder of the camaraderie and camaraderie within the industry. The success of Dead Outlaw and the recognition it has received further solidify its status as a must-see production on Broadway.