He Lived Quietly for Decades. Now the ‘Nice Fella’ Next Door Is Accused of Stabbing Woman 17 Times

Florida Police Arrest 72-Year-Old Man in Connection with Cold Case Murder of 23-Year-Old Woman

The St. Cloud Police Department in Florida recently made a significant breakthrough in a 34-year-old cold case involving the murder of a young single mother. Gene Stuller, 72, has been arrested and charged with the murder of 27-year-old Julia Wilbanks, who was brutally stabbed to death in 1991. Police Chief Douglas Goerke announced the arrest at a news conference, attributing advancements in DNA technology, specifically genetic genealogy, as key to linking Stuller to the crime.

Wilbanks tragically lost her life after sustaining approximately 17 stab wounds, including fatal injuries to her heart. Her body lay undiscovered on the side of the road for over 24 hours before being found by a group of passing motorists who alerted the authorities. The identification and subsequent arrest of Gene Stuller mark a significant development in a case that had remained unsolved for decades, bringing closure to Wilbanks’ family and friends.

Neighbours of Stuller in Apopka, a suburb north of Orlando, expressed shock at the news of his arrest, with one resident describing him as a “nice fella” and expressing disbelief at the allegations. Despite the outward appearance of being “outgoing” and “jolly,” Stuller now faces charges of second-degree murder and disturbing a body in relation to Wilbanks’ death. The sudden revelation of his alleged involvement serves as a stark reminder of how well we may think we know those around us.

Chief Goerke revealed that the cold case was reopened in 2012, but it wasn’t until recently that a DNA match was identified, leading to Stuller’s surveillance and eventual arrest. The collection of DNA evidence from a straw used by Stuller played a crucial role in linking him to the crime scene, highlighting the evolving role of forensic science in solving long-dormant cases. Stuller is set to appear in court to face the charges brought against him, as the legal process seeks to deliver justice for Wilbanks and her loved ones.

The diligent efforts of law enforcement in pursuing justice for Julia Wilbanks reflect a commitment to resolving unsolved cases and holding perpetrators accountable. Chief Goerke emphasised the importance of leveraging technological advances to revisit cold cases, underscoring how scientific progress can provide new avenues for seeking truth and closure. The arrest of Gene Stuller underscores the enduring impact of investigative work and serves as a testament to the perseverance of those dedicated to upholding justice.

As communities come to terms with the shocking revelations surrounding the arrest of Stuller, the case serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities that lie beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary lives. The unfolding developments shed light on the enduring impact of crimes committed years ago and highlight the unwavering commitment of law enforcement to pursue justice, regardless of the passage of time. The arrest of Stuller marks a significant milestone in the quest for closure for the family of Julia Wilbanks and underscores the importance of continued efforts to seek resolution in long-standing cold cases.

The case of Julia Wilbanks, once relegated to the annals of unsolved mysteries, now stands as a testament to the relentless pursuit of justice and the enduring impact of forensic advancements in solving crimes. As the legal process unfolds, the memory of Wilbanks and the pursuit of accountability for her tragic death remain at the forefront. The arrest of Gene Stuller represents a significant step towards closure in a case that has haunted both the community and law enforcement for over three decades.