AJ McLean Recalls Fist Fight with Nick Carter Over a Comic Book — Which a Naked Kevin Richardson Tried to Break Up

AJ McLean, a member of the iconic boy band Backstreet Boys, shared a nostalgic and humorous anecdote during a panel at the 90s Con 2025. The singer, now 47, reminisced about a fist fight he had with fellow bandmate Nick Carter over a comic book. The incident occurred during their teenage years when McLean was struggling with acne and Carter teased him by calling him “pizza face.” McLean, feeling provoked, ended up accidentally setting fire to Carter’s comic book, leading to a physical altercation between the two.

Reflecting on the incident, McLean described the dramatic scene that unfolded at bandmate Kevin Richardson’s apartment, where the fight took place. With Carter living with Richardson and other bandmates at the time, the situation escalated as the comic book went up in flames, and a scuffle ensued between McLean and Carter. The chaotic moment was further heightened when Richardson emerged from the shower in a towel, only to have it fall off, while Howie Dorough sat back and watched the drama unfold with amusement.

Despite the scuffle, the Backstreet Boys have continued to make music and entertain fans over the years. McLean recently hinted at an upcoming residency in Las Vegas, where they will bring their 1999 album “Millennium” back to life. He shared his excitement about the prospect of the band performing together once again and the emotional response he expects from Richardson during the shows. The residency is set to be a tribute to their loyal fanbase, who have supported them throughout their 32 years together.

McLean’s revelations at the panel offered fans a glimpse into the behind-the-scenes dynamics of one of the most popular boy bands of the ’90s. The camaraderie and occasional conflicts among band members exemplify the journey they have shared throughout their enduring career. The upcoming Las Vegas residency is poised to be a special event for both the band and their dedicated followers, celebrating the music that has defined a generation.

As McLean continues to reflect on the past and look towards the future with the Backstreet Boys, his stories serve as a reminder of the bond that has kept the group together for decades. The blend of nostalgia, humour, and shared experiences showcased at the 90s Con panel offers a glimpse into the world of ’90s music icons and the enduring legacy they have built. Fans can look forward to more tales and performances from the Backstreet Boys as they prepare to take the stage once again in Las Vegas.

The 90s Con event provided a platform for McLean and other ’90s music stars to connect with fans, share memories, and celebrate the era that defined their careers. As the music industry continues to evolve, these moments of reflection and nostalgia offer a unique opportunity to revisit the music and memories that have shaped pop culture. McLean’s candid retelling of his clash with Carter over a comic book serves as a testament to the camaraderie and occasional conflicts that have been part of the Backstreet Boys’ journey since their early days.